Skip to main content
The SkilledVisa Record An independent monitor of UK work-visa policy
Compliance

Illegal Working Civil Penalty: Employer Liability Explained

How the illegal working civil penalty scheme works: maximum fines per worker, the statutory excuse, and objection and appeal routes for employers.

Skilledvisa Editorial 7 min read
Illustration representing an illegal working civil penalty notice and employer compliance checks in the UK

Illustration representing an illegal working civil penalty notice and employer compliance checks in the UK

TL;DR: The illegal working civil penalty can reach £60,000 per illegal worker for repeat offending employers. A compliant right to work check carried out before employment begins gives an employer a statutory excuse against liability. Employers served with a penalty notice can object, appeal to the County Court or High Court, or pay within set deadlines to secure a reduction.

The illegal working civil penalty scheme allows the Home Office to fine employers who employ someone without the right to work in the UK. The scheme is administered under the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006 and is enforced through referral, notification and penalty stages set out in Home Office guidance. Employers found liable receive a referral notice, followed by a civil penalty notice confirming the amount owed, unless they can demonstrate a statutory excuse.

How much is the illegal working civil penalty?

The current maximum civil penalty is £60,000 per illegal worker for a second or subsequent breach within a three-year period. A first breach carries a maximum penalty of £45,000 per illegal worker. These figures reflect the increase that took effect under updated Home Office guidance, which significantly raised the previous penalty levels. The actual amount charged depends on factors including whether the employer has breached the rules before, whether mitigating action was taken, and whether the employer cooperated with the Home Office during the compliance visit or investigation.

According to Home Office guidance, the penalty is calculated per illegal worker, meaning an employer found to be employing multiple individuals without the right to work can face a cumulative penalty running into hundreds of thousands of pounds.

Mitigating factors that can reduce the penalty include reporting suspected illegal working to the Home Office, cooperating during an investigation, and having no previous breaches on record. Employers who hold a sponsor licence and are found liable for a civil penalty may also face separate consequences for that licence, including suspension or revocation, which is addressed in guidance on sponsor licence requirements.

What is the statutory excuse and how is it established?

An employer avoids liability for a civil penalty by establishing what is known as a statutory excuse. This excuse is established by carrying out a correctly conducted right to work check before the individual starts work, and repeating that check where the individual holds time-limited permission to stay. The check must follow one of three accepted methods: a manual document check of original documents from the Home Office list, a Home Office online right to work check using a share code, or an identity verification check carried out through the use of identity service provider technology for British and Irish citizens holding a valid passport.

A properly conducted check, retained on file with evidence of the date it was carried out, provides a continuous statutory excuse for as long as the employment continues, provided repeat checks are carried out where required for those with time-limited status. Employers who fail to conduct any check, or who conduct a check incorrectly, cannot rely on the statutory excuse and become liable for the full civil penalty if the worker is later found to lack permission to work. Detailed procedural requirements for carrying out these checks are covered in guidance on right to work checks.

The statutory excuse does not apply where an employer knew, or had reasonable cause to believe, that the employee did not have the right to work, even if a check was nominally carried out. In such cases, the employer may face criminal liability rather than only a civil penalty.

What happens after a civil penalty notice is issued?

Where the Home Office determines that an employer is liable, it issues a civil penalty notice setting out the amount due, the reasons for liability, and the deadline for payment, objection or appeal. Employers generally have 28 days from the date of the notice to respond.

Objecting to the penalty

An employer can object to a civil penalty notice on specified grounds, including that the employer is not liable, that a statutory excuse applies, that the level of penalty is wrong, or that the notice was issued to the wrong employer. The objection must be made in writing within the 28-day period using the process set out in the notice itself. The Home Office then reconsiders the case and issues an objection outcome notice, which may uphold, reduce, increase or cancel the original penalty.

Appealing to the court

If an employer disagrees with the outcome of an objection, an appeal can be made to the County Court in England and Wales, the Sheriff Court in Scotland, or the County Court in Northern Ireland. The appeal must normally be lodged within 28 days of the objection outcome notice. The court can cancel the penalty, reduce it, or uphold it in full. Employers considering an appeal are expected to have already exhausted the objection stage, since the court generally only considers cases where the Home Office’s internal review has already taken place.

Payment options

Employers who accept liability can pay the penalty in full or, in some circumstances, apply for payment by instalments. The Home Office guidance also sets out a fast payment option, under which an employer who pays within a set period, typically within 21 days of the penalty notice and before lodging an objection, may be eligible for a reduction of the penalty amount, often by around 30 per cent. Failure to pay, object or appeal within the specified timescales can result in enforcement action, including registration of the debt and recovery through the civil courts.

How does this affect sponsors and employers more broadly?

For businesses operating under the Skilled Worker route, a civil penalty for illegal working can have consequences beyond the fine itself. Sponsors are expected to maintain compliant right to work checking systems across their entire workforce, not only sponsored employees, and failures identified during a compliance visit can affect the sponsor’s rating within the Sponsorship Management System. A civil penalty linked to poor right to work practices can therefore trigger wider scrutiny of an employer’s sponsor licence, including its ability to issue a Certificate of Sponsorship for future hires.

Common questions

Does a civil penalty apply if the employer genuinely did not know the worker lacked permission? Liability can still arise even without knowledge, unless the employer carried out a compliant right to work check and holds the statutory excuse. Genuine lack of knowledge is not itself a defence if no check, or an incorrect check, was carried out.

Can a civil penalty be issued alongside criminal prosecution? Yes. Civil penalties apply to employers who are negligent in their checks, while criminal prosecution is reserved for employers who knowingly or with reasonable cause to believe employed someone without the right to work. The two routes are separate and can, in some circumstances, both be pursued.

Is there a public record of employers penalised for illegal working? The Home Office has previously published lists of employers who received civil penalties for illegal working as part of its wider enforcement reporting, though inclusion and format of such publications can vary over time according to current guidance.

Information, not advice — reported from official sources under the SkilledVisa standards.

Share
Link copied to clipboard!